Society has changed a lot since de Beauvoir wrote The Second Sex, but there are still conventions all around us that enforce a female’s belief in her immanence, her permanent and unchanging identity as an object. Think, for example, of the many mainstream women’s magazines that ask women what their “true” color is, or to find out what kind of hairstyle or perfume fits who she really “is”—these are all subtle methods of telling a woman that she has a constant, “true,” unchanging self to uncover. This is quite different from the typical men’s magazine, where the common articles are about objects (cars, electronics, hot women) for the man to act with/upon. Women are told to be, not encouraged to do or make.
So the mirror does more than satisfy superficial urges; gazing into the mirror is, we are led to believe, a way to puzzle out who we are. The act of looking at yourself is—despite your knowing better—affected by the swarmy men who whisper as you scurry down the street that you have beautiful windows to the soul; you go home to peer into glass and block out the “bad” flesh to locate that soul. De Beauvoir spelled all this out 60-odd years ago so that bright, educated women like me would not fall into this trap of staring at our reflections to find ourselves in all our glorious immanence. And yet there I was, locking myself into the handicapped stall—the one with the bigger mirror—to study my appearance, just to make sure that I was still there, and hating myself for it.
And here I still am. The shame of my compulsion to look into mirrors has grown over the years, but the shame is not enough to break the habit. Hatred feeds hatred. “Hating my body” barely kisses the surface (I can block out the thighs, the arms, the fat that suffocates the cheekbones; besides, it is difficult for me to imagine sincerely hating flesh): it is hating myself for being such a female, such a bad woman, compulsively drawn to the mirror even though I know better. And then—digging deeper still—hating myself for hating myself during these moments of entrapment. For I know that this hatred plays the same tricks—is as intoxicating, and provides the same false sense of fullness—as the pure enthrallment of the mirror herself.
And yet.
There is no hunger, only thoughts about hunger that gnaw away at the place where my mind should be: first, the desire to be hungry so I can look better; then, the desire to be full as punishment for being so stupid as to waste my life thinking about how I look. Next, hating feeling full because now I will get fat, and moreover I will be stuffed with silly thoughts like I’m going to get fat. There is also the guilt of feeling full because I was duped into bad eating habits, which means weak womanhood, because I put the food to my mouth not out of hunger but because of some idea about what it means for me to be a woman; and the hatred of feeling full because feeling full is like feeling plenitude, immanence, weighed down to the ground and unable to transcend. The desire to be light enough to transcend: the desire for hunger.
Itchy. It feels itchy, like there are ants making an anthill out of the inside of my skull, their infinite tiny pricklish little legs tickling the tender bits of my mind. I see insects where there are none: jumping back at a nonexistent speck on the floor; nightmares of roaches tumbling onto my naked self when I turn on the shower faucet; close my eyes and there is a giant bedbug like a crest stuck on the wall in front of me. I feel like a hysterical woman. I feel like I cannot go on: voices and voices and voices breaking apart and doubling back and shouting and whimpering and apologizing and for every voice there is a new one yanking the other back from behind. They are digging a grave: scratching into the place where the mind should be a giant…deep…hole…
Hole? Like how a woman is a hole? Maybe I am just thinking like a real woman! I will write about it. If I cannot escape this hole then at least I can spit it out of my body by turning it into art! But wait. Aren’t I not supposed to take symbols seriously? And who am I to suppose that other women have this paralyzing, spiraling anxiety? Bad me! “A woman is a person who defines herself as such,” I read somewhere. A woman is not a person desperately trying not to fall into their hole! You are a bad feminist for your thoughts: women are totally fine! Why put another weak woman out there in the world? You need to create strong women, role models to help out fools like yourself. Women are fine. If you are not fine, do not write. Wait, what are you doing? Why are you not writing? You are acting just like a woman: unable to finish anything that you start! Awwwww. Pity pitiless you, destined to be a weak woman just like all your forefathers and weaker still for believing such trash. Destined to be a weak woman and a bad feminist in a—what is it called—post-feminist world!





























This was incredible, and so completely helpful and relevant to what I’m going through right now.
Log in to replyThank you, Rookie.
THIS COMMENT FOR ME TOO
(it sounds unserious but I’m being totally serious. Thank you so much, Anna!)
Log in to replyWow,that was amazing! I loved the style of writing as well, like a really personal diary crossed with an essay. But not a boring essay- one that’s actually stimulating and relevant. I totally get it, as well, there’s this whole interesting guilt complex I have about how, as I’m relatively privileged, I’m betraying myself by being what you called a weak feminist. Feminism is awesome, and it’s really done masses for women all over the world, but perhaps it’s also pushed a lot of issues under the surface. It’s like we had our time to speak, and now things are so great for women anyone speaking out is labeled as another “angry whinging feminist type”.
Log in to replyBut the truth is that things are really not “so great for women.” In many countries all over the world women are still treated as sub-human. In some parts of Africa, Asia, the Middle East, women are treated like they’re worthless. And even in more “advanced” places like the United States, women are still looked down upon and not treated equally. We may have come a long way since a few decades ago, but we haven’t come as far as we and other people, especially men, would like to think. I mean, women barely got the right to vote less than a hundred years ago. LESS THAN A HUNDRED YEARS AGO. That is insane! Sometimes I think that feminism has given everybody the false idea that everything is good now and we can stop trying, when the truth is, we have to work harder than ever now.
Log in to replyHey, you’re totally right. I was thinking more on a personal level, because I’m extremely lucky not to have encountered much prejudice in my life, but yes, women get a terrible deal all over the world. I was reading this article about female mutilation the other day and it made me want to hurl…
Log in to replyJust perfect. Wow. I’m speechless.
Log in to replyso gooooood
Log in to replywow. just… wow
Log in to replyThis is by far one of the best articles I’ve read. Long, but so interesting that I’ll remember it forever.
Log in to replyI think this was such an incredible article but I’m not sure if it made me feel better or worse. For me my main insecurity isn’t my body but my intelligence, and feeling like I lack an opinion in group discussions. I guess it all comes under the same umbrella, about shying away from certain things or aspects of yourself for fear of sounding or looking like an idiot. If I want to squeal over a cashmere sweater can I do so unashamedly or will I just seem vapid? And if I refrain from doing so for the fear of seeming vapid am I just caving in to a different type of expectation and trying to be above that when I’m really not? Or am I just squealing over the cashmere sweater in the first place because I’m a woman and society expects me to be interested in cashmere sweaters instead of having a real input?
I’m not entirely sure what I’m trying to say so I’m gonna bow out, but your article really made me think, so thank you.
Log in to replyAnna, for me, it’s intelligence as well as body insecurity, but I feel you so much here. Every day: do I raise my hand in science, do I speak up in the English discussion, do I get outwardly excited about the New Teen Movie coming out? I don’t want to seem stupid, and I almost always feel I am. I wish it were easier to see things — intellectual things — as subjective, and that everyone’s opinion is truly equal, but I can’t even see my own opinion that way.
And this is a beautiful, well-written article. I love Simone de Beauvoir, and this all definitely resonated with me. Thank you.
Log in to replyIf this article made you think you are really smart Anna, because inteligence is not about knowing so many words or issues, it’s about thinking about everyday episodes and learn.
Log in to replyI find that I struggle with the intelligence issue quite a bit, but even more than that, I fight with the concept of my “self” as a static notion. That somehow I cannot hold contradictory opinions – that being a hypocrite is not part of the human condition. We all have blind spots about ourselves and sometimes I think about a thing and I decide on my opinion and then later, I have a discussion or I read something that gives me new information and I change my mind. But once I have given a public opinion about a thing, then it is somehow shameful to have come to a deeper understanding of that thing, through reflection and writing and realize that there is something else going on, beyond what you first saw. How can it be bad to acknowledge such a transformation? Why the punishment heaped on those who learn from their mistakes?
p.s. Your comment provoked my thoughts, as the article did for you – theory of transmission in action. Lovely. Thanks!
Log in to replyyes. yes and YES. you and me are in the same boat. wow.
Log in to replyIs it enough to just point at things that are wrong? To call attention to things, say to people, “this shouldn’t happen”. Do we have to take action, or can we acknowledge things, heighten awareness before letting them dull and fade once more? Is being mindful enough?
Log in to replyI love The Second Sex! To me this book is a better representation of feminism than books like The Feminine Mystique. Simone de Beauvoir is, in my opinion, the author to read when figuring out feminist thought, not Betty Friedan.
Log in to replyWhat a fascinating article! This part resonated particularly with me: “Women, on the other hand, come to understand the world in its immanence. Immanence means existing within—in other words, they see the world as it already exists”.
wow, just wow
http://www.pompandceremony.blogspot.com
Log in to replyDefinitely worth the long read, I loved this piece and found it very motivating and uplifting, even though it covered some sad emotions, such as shame! A good balance, it’s really nice to hear the opinions of another persons journey to being a FEMINIISTTT.
Log in to replythis is excellent, thank you xxxx
Log in to replyMale beauty is a sign of transcendence, that of woman has the passivity of immanence… WOW
I´m so glad I´ve finally read this. I had this discussion with my boyfriend like a week ago. He said that women are just like men, that they hurt and judge like men do, and I was agree in some way… but he couldn´t understand my point, that women have been always judged about their looks or how good they were in “girl stuff”, like pleasing men or cooking. And I hate that icons about us, give man the possibility to call us frivolous or stupid if we talk or do “girl stuff”, and all other things that are not related to our immanence, must be for men. I really apreciate this article. GIRLS, READ THIS. And be so proud about being a girl and even more, about being a HUMAN BEING (that can cook, have children, think, read, create, love, be free… everything), a light body, a dream in the earth.
Log in to replyOH MY GOSH THIS IS BEAUTIFUL. This is beautiful. This is so exciting. Thank you, Anna McConnell, and thank you, Rookie.
I’ve been focusing so much on “being” lately… judging myself so much on what I look like and the facial expressions I make and the way I laugh and the way I think… I haven’t had time to do anything, when doing things despite — no, not despite, with and through — my insecurities and gross thoughts and self-disgust would actually heal me and make me stronger, or, at the very least, help heal someone, or make this entire conversation stronger. THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU.
Log in to replyThis was exactly what I needed today, thank you so much Rookie you are perfect. <3
Log in to replyThis article… wow. So many points are addressed. It is both reassuring and thought-provoking. This has to be the most profound Rookie article I’ve ever read, and I want to sincerely thank everyone involved with its creation and publication. http://deepblueoceanofnoise.tumblr.com/
Log in to replyThis is quite possibly the most relatable piece of writing I’ve ever read. Really. Thank you, Anna McConnell. I don’t think I can thank you enough.
Log in to replyThis is a beautiful article. And I do agree–I think that it’s so important for people not to feel alienated by works done by people who are supposedly better off than them, who have supposedly reached this social ideal of what they’re supposed to be. I personally feel more comforted knowing that I am not alone in my insecurities and suffering, rather than reading stuff like “How to be Happy” articles or whatever by people whom I just can’t help but think of as having it all, and never having had to suffer before. In a way, the absence of people admitting their insecurities creates this distance between the reader and the creator who’s trying to make themself look better.
Log in to replyI have read articles on Rookie that have changed my life. This is one of them.
Log in to replyI have thought a lot about this article over the past day, and I now realized what troubled me about it. Raw honesty is all right, but if we are to remain at orgies of honesty and acceprance for the imperfect, then I think we would be well losing hope on progress.
Log in to replyI so agree with you, Ana. I think we need examples of both honesty and strength.
Log in to replyI AM VERY SKINNY AND THAT MAKES ME UPSET BECAUSE PEOPLE ASSUME I DONT EAT. I WANT TO WEAR MAKE UP SO BADLY BUT I AM AFRAID TO.
Log in to replydo whatever you want to do if you want to wear makeup do it. who gives a shit what others think. do it do it do ittt.
Log in to replyI know what you mean, how people automatically think thin girls are constantly dieting or something. My friends is very thin, and not because she doesn’t eat (her mum and sister both have the same figure) and some people automatically assume she’s constantly dieting or half-jokingly say its like she has an eating disorder. I know a girl who doesn’t like her, and one of her complaints, along with she’s annoying and “such a drama queen”, was “she’s too thin”.
I hate it how people equate fat with unhealthy, thin with healthy (unless you’re “too” thin, then its “woah girl, eat more. But not too much, or you’ll end up a fat ugly pig and no one will love you.”). Or equate fat with eating too much, thin with eating too little.
But anyway, if you want to wear make-up, do it. just do it. And if you change your mind and don’t want to do it any more, just don’t. (I know, that can be easier said than done…)
Log in to replyGod, I loved this. It makes me feel “full” in the best possible way.
Log in to replythis is amazing. But truly. Everything we’ve all wanted to say for such a long time. Thank you, you’ve inspired me to write again.
Log in to replyThis is a brilliant article! The only problem I have is really minimal, and it’s only because it seems like Anna is dissing Simone Weil, who I have had a huge crush on since, like, forever and a day. SHE WAS SO AMAZING, GUYS.
Log in to replyIncredible.
Log in to replyThat was incredibly raw and wonderfully written. Thanks so much for sharing. You’ve given great insight to some of the traps of being a woman (the way society has taught us to be rather than what women are striving for) that we can all so easily fall into without realizing it. Can a person grow that much from reading one article? because I feel like I have.
Log in to replycrazy good writing, I just feel like this does not relate to me at all
Log in to replyYour article ROCKED!! Its so personal in the way it captures my attention and original! <3 LOVED IT!!
Log in to replyoh my Goddess
Log in to replyThis is what I think about every day.
Log in to replyThis has changed the way I think, or more importantly allowed me to think the way I always have.
Log in to replyI relate to the eating but not having any eating disorders. I hate mostly that when I see skinny girls or hear skinny girls talk skinny things, I eat. They make me so hungry. It’s almost like I feel insecure about how insecure they are and I eat and I over eat. I get hungry and then I feel sick, but full, but never worry about it too much. Hell I got my muesli bar out as soon as my eyes surpassed that sentence.
Log in to replyI’m really bummed that you included an image of a white girl in a headdress in this post. Cultural appropriation is really gross and I’m sorry to see it on the site.
Log in to replyHey, you’re right, and we’re sorry. I should have caught that, but that is such an iconic image of Kate Moss that I didn’t even take IN that she’s wearing a headdress. Not an excuse!
Log in to replyJust had so many realisations reading this that I am now in tears. Such an incredible piece of writting!
Log in to replySpot on.
Log in to replyI have no words.
Log in to replyWow wow wow wow.
Log in to replyI love this so much, ‘Whenever a woman has an ugly feeling, there is the accompanying guilt of feeling that she is a weak female, and then the double-guilt for feeling that guilt’.
I feel guilty for witholding, for staying in the shadows sometimes. I think the main issue is that no matter where we turn, there is an expectation waiting for us to fail. I want reality and although we do need a strong rolemodel occassionally, I just feel guilt when i withold.
This was an amazing article, thank you.
This is one of the most beautiful and thought-provoking articles I have ever read on Rookie (as a few others have mentioned) and I assure you that I will be thinking about it for a long while and re-reading it often. Thank you so much for this.
Log in to replyAmazing. There have been so many discussions on Facebook about feminism and humanism recently, and it’s gotten pretty disturbing. Mainly because a few of my straight male friends think that feminism and humanism are the same thing. They’re not the SAME THING! Feminism is about embracing a cause, fighting for something. To tell a feminist to stop fighting for equal treatment is like telling a starving person to stop fighting to eat. These guys always shoot you down whenever you say something about women’s rights, and act like we need to give it up already, become “humanists”. Really I think they’re just hoping that we feminists have given up the fight, so the western world can go ahead and keep being a male-dominated society. They keep trying to convince me that the world doesn’t need activists, and that everyone should just rely on themselves for everything, and that’s how the feminist discussion turns into a moral discussion. That’s how they divert our attention, and try to convey to us that feminism is a lost, dead cause. They think women are as equal to men as they’re going to get, and it would be more productive to focus on other endeavors. Can you believe these guys? Does anyone else GET ME? I’m so floored by the way these guys think. How can you not see the OBVIOUS INEQUALITY?! Here’s one example: Look at our United States government. Talk about inequality! Women don’t even come close when it comes to MAKING DECISIONS ON GOVERNMENT POLICY and REPRESENTING our mixed population of men AND women. I just want someone to understand!!
Log in to replyI don’t understand how people can say that sexism doesn’t exist any more. Its right there in front of our eyes! It frustrates me when people try to deny women’s experiences and BLATANT REALITY. It shows how male-dominated (and racist and hetro-normative for that matter) our society is, that even when inequality exists and there are FACTS AND STATISTICS THAT SHOW IT, NOT JUST MY STUPID WHINGING GIRL THOUGHTS, people are still satisfied with the idea that we are all totally, 100% equal.
Log in to replyThis may sound rad, but I believe that until pregnancy/abortion is no longer a discussion shared with men or litigated in courts, but a decision made solely by an individual woman; and until women are legally allowed to sell (i.e., a demonstration of OWNERSHIP) our own bodies, we will feel DEEP DOWN they are the property of public domain, and should look the way society at large (from the male perspective) would dictate.
We should have complete say regarding our own bodies.
We should have 100% equal pay.
We need to have childcare be a paid position, as it is work. The most difficult and the most important work.
Yeah~we need to be fighting harder than ever now…and that’s precisely why society keeps turning up the heat in the LOOKS department…reminding us to tend to these bodies, because they don’t belong to us and we need to answer to society for the condition/appearance of them.
Simone De Bouvier is apparently still relevant. Thanks for including succinct parts of her writings. I had not had a chance to read that far back but it sounds like she got to the crux of the matter for sure.
Log in to replyRelating to strong role models… role models can be strong and imperfect. In fact, it’s even better to have “normal”, imperfect characters and real life role models; in some ways, it’s less alienating and more honest.
Log in to replyWhat you describe as weakness seems to be human imperfection to me.
Thanks Anna,
This was so informative and so inspiring. The first thing I did after reading it was return to page one and read it again. Please write more or show me where I can read more of your work?
C xxx
Log in to replyoh man i love this so much.
Log in to replythis article deserves a slow clap. its brilliant.
Log in to replyI made an account just so I could comment on how much I loved this article and how thankful I am for it.
Log in to replyEveryone else has pretty much articulated my thoughts but really, this is awesome.
I agree, this is an important article. There’s this major subject in our lives which I guess most of us share yet hide, those bad thoughts and feelings of inferiority or weakness as a female. For me it’s sometimes really physical, like I can actually feel inferiority, insecurities or the shame of battles that I’ve lost crawling down my body and centering around my girl parts. What’s most interesting is how being a feminist and thinking about feminism doesn’t make us immune, more the opposite. It can turn what could have been a fleeting moment of personal insecurity into a big mess of gendered anger, self hate, shame, and the cycle of guilt. The other day my boyfriend was complaining about how he was always bad at sports and he hates his lack of coordination. All I could think was: nobody ever told you you’re bad at sports because you’re a girl, so why do you care? I couldn’t imagine caring about feeling inferior when it’s not a feminist issue!
Log in to replythank you rookie. just crying and crying and crying and trying to find words to describe how relevant and poignant this article is.
Log in to replyThank you so much, this could not have come at a better time ! I was followed home from work by a creepy dude, and he said disgusting things, and I didn’t react like a strong feminist woman. I felt like such a bad feminist and a weak woman ! I feel a bit better now… Thank you…
Log in to replyI recognize myself in this text so much. It was very interesting and inspiring. I feel like this strong woman” female role model thing is turning out ridicilous. We don’t need “strong women” we need women who are portrayed as human beings, because women ARE human beings. If you find a perfect human being you are probably romantizising and don’t know the person very well. (At all…)
I’ve felt the pressure to be a better feminist since I first bagun to become concious of the inequality of the sexes. Like I didn’t have the right to call myself a feminist if I didn’t do something RIGHT now to crush the patriarchy or whatever. I still have hose feelings even now. But it makes me feel a little better to know that everybody feels like that now and then.
Log in to replyAm I the only one who was slightly horrified by the content of this article? I’m sorry but when you describe guilt about your “feminine weakness”, I don’t know what the heck you are talking about. The things the writer is experiencing are just part of the human condition, and a serious lack of self confidence. These problems are not uniquely feminine.
Log in to replyI completely agree and it’s upsetting that this book and article is attached to feminism because it’s not about that and if anything it’s contradictory. To say feminism is being solely dedicated to a man or a God is completely ridiculous. It upsets me that people would say that they agree with this or it saved their life because it’s so mislead. It gives off the notion of women being hysterical, which is perfectly acceptable, but not a feminine characteristic. I got a bitter feeling running through me when I read this and I feel unsettled to know that it was published. I plead with those that agree with the above person to find some support. It’s not about being a woman it’s about being human. I understand the issues raised here and the imagery is spot on, but the explanation and theories are those of someone who is trying to find comfort in loneliness by dragging the whole of womankind down with her. I’m not saying that she’s the only one who’s ever felt like this. But I strongly believe it’s not because she’s a woman, it’s because she’s very, very lonely.
Log in to replyIt may not affect your other feelings about the article, but this is a pretty drastic misunderstanding: “To say feminism is being solely dedicated to a man or a God is completely ridiculous.” The author is describing Simone de Beauvoir’s characterization of attitudes women fall into to avoid confronting their freedom–these are NOT examples of feminism, they are examples of negative outcomes for women.
In the event you meant to type “To say femininity is …”, I’d disagree with you (because I think the author is talking about her/her friends’ anecdotal experience) but I’d get where you’re coming from.
Log in to replyI think this might’ve saved my life.
Log in to replyTruly Brilliant
Log in to replyWow. Um, wow. That really sums up so much of what it feels to be a young woman. It’s the constant struggle between delight in “femininity” and then disgust at that delight and then this constant cycle that we get stuck in. This is beautiful.
Log in to replyThis article is true for me on so many levels.
Log in to reply